
My Story
About Game Day Catering Co.
Game Day Catering Co. was born from experience.
As a parent of youth travel athletes, I’ve spent countless weekends at tournaments and long days at the fields. I’ve seen firsthand how difficult it can be to find a good meal when your team is playing multiple games throughout the day.
Sometimes the only options are concession-stand food, snacks or overpriced delivery apps that simply aren’t ideal for an athlete who still has a game to play. And we’ve all been there for those 6pm games where you have to decide to have dinner at 4pm or stop for fast food at 9pm on your way home.
And when a team wants to order something better, someone usually has to take a massive team order, find a local deli or restaurant willing to prepare it, leave the field to pick it up, and potentially miss part of the game. Delivery apps aren’t always much help either. Finding a field in a crowded tournament complex can be difficult, and many restaurants simply won’t deliver directly to the fields.
I believe there should be a better option.
Game Day Catering Co. was created to bring fresh, homemade, family-style meals directly to the teams and families who need them.
My menu is inspired by something that has always been important to me: the traditional Sunday family dinner I grew up with in an Italian family. There was something special about everyone gathering around the table, sharing a meal, talking, laughing, and simply enjoying each other’s company. It’s a tradition I’m proud to continue with my own kids today.
That same feeling is what I hope to bring to the ballfields and tournament fields.
My meals focus on homestyle Italian favorites made with fresh, quality ingredients, with many of the ingredients coming straight from my own garden whenever possible. Every tray is prepared with the same care I would put into a meal for my own family.
Because Game Day Catering Co. isn’t just about feeding a team.
It’s about bringing people together.
I’ve seen how sharing a meal after a game can bring players closer and give families a chance to sit down, relax, and build relationships away from the field. In a world where everyone is constantly rushing from one game to the next, I want to create a reason to slow down for a little while and enjoy a good meal together.
There are so many great tournaments and sporting events on Long Island, but too often, good food isn’t part of the experience.
Game Day Catering Co. is here to change that.
My Promise
I make fresh food with top-quality ingredients — built to keep athletes, coaches, and families fueled from the first game to the last.
What parents are saying
★★★★★
“Absolutely 5/5! The food was incredible, everything was homemade, fresh, and tasted great. What really stood out was how light the food was. It was the perfect balance of delicious, homemade food that actually fuels you without leaving you feeling sluggish. You can tell they put real care into everything they make. Highly recommend this catering company for any team or game day!”
“We had the most incredible experience with Sunday Sauce through Game Day Catering Co.! The pasta was absolutely incredible, and the meatballs were truly exceptional. Everything was fresh, delicious, and full of flavor. You can tell a lot of care goes into the food! We will definitely be using them again and again. Highly recommend! You won’t be disappointed! ❤️”
“Matt’s food is incredible. My favorite is the meatballs! Pure 🔥”
★★★★★
“We absolutely loved the Italian Family Sunday Feast at our Sunday night baseball game! The food was fantastic, and it was such a lifesaver having it right at the field after our late night game. Instead of having to stop somewhere for fast food on the way home with the kids, we had a delicious, homemade meal waiting for us to enjoy with the team. So convenient, and the food was seriously amazing! Would highly recommend!!”
“Hey Matt, just wanted to let you know that the food was amazing. We are so happy that we found Game Day Catering Co. The soccer team, parents and coaching staff loved everything about the experience!!! See ya soon!!”
“Game Day Catering Co. is not only a great idea for families attending tournaments all day long, but the food is also delicious and high-quality. Most tournaments we’ve attended have had Sign Up Genius’s with snack foods that have little substance but this allowed us to eat a great meal before we got home at 9pm. Parents walking by our set up had people intrigued and saying how great of an idea GDC is. We will definitely be using them here on out.”
FAQ
How far ahead should I order?
I suggest at least 3 days, so I have time to shop, prep, and plan. Need it sooner? Call or text 631-466-2980 and I’ll do my best to make it work.
Will the food arrive hot?
Yes. I deliver in an insulated carrier that keeps food at temperature for 4 to 6 hours, so everything arrives hot and there’s nothing to reheat.
How much is delivery?
Delivery is free within 5 miles. Farther out, there’s a small fee based on distance. Enter your address in the request form and you’ll see your fee right away.
Is there a minimum order?
No minimum. The one exception is a long trip: for drop-offs more than 90 minutes away there’s a $300 food minimum and a flat $75 delivery fee.
Do you provide plates, utensils, or tables?
Not yet. Please bring your own for now.
How do I pay?
When I confirm your order, I’ll send a payment link or sort out another option with you (Venmo, Apple Cash, or cash on delivery).
Is a deposit required? What if I need to cancel?
For orders over $500, I collect a 25% deposit when I confirm your order, and it comes off your total. Cancel 48 or more hours ahead and it’s refunded.
How many people does a tray feed?
A half tray feeds 8–10 and a full tray feeds 15–20. A 3-foot hero feeds 12–15 and a 6-foot hero feeds 24–30. These are typical estimates and can vary with portion size, appetites, and whether you’re serving other dishes.
What about food allergies or dietary needs?
Tell me in your request and I’ll tell you exactly what I can and can’t do.